Medium red. Precise, vibrant aromas of cherry, raspberry, crushed stone, rose petal and white pepper, with a light earthy nuance. Then juicy and perfumed but youthfully imploded on the palate, and in need of at least a couple years of patience. The rising finish perfumes the mouth. This is much more classic than the 2009 version.

Mugnier's 2008 Chambolle-Musigny is a gorgeous, translucent wine laced with sweet dark cherries, menthol, spices and licorice. It is totally striking and inviting from start to finish, with tons of perfume and a seductive, enticing personality. The 2008 doesn't quite have the immediacy of The 2009, but readers lucky enough to find it won't be disappointed. It should be even better in another few years, once the tannins soften a touch.